19 Comments
User's avatar
Janice Falls's avatar

When I am in doubt about my writing, ie almost always, I try to remember this short poem by Sean Thomas Dougherty titled Why Bother? Because right now, there is / someone / out there with / a wound / in the exact shape / of your words. Your words are the exact shape of many wounds James, thank goodness you bother. xoxo

Ann Bodling's avatar

Yes and yes and yes! So good to know that all of us have self-doubt at times and that our words touch people anyway. I'll remember this poem next spring when our field is full of frittilaries and violets. Thank you, James.

Jan Haag's avatar

Wonderful poem, James! I love the synchronicity between your writing of it and Alex's prompt. And oh, I'm right there with that 8-year-old poet, trembling and reading, and I am SO there, adding to that thunderous applause... then and now!

Melinda Coppola's avatar

Deep gratitude to you for these words and for modeling this showing up thing. Time and time again, when writers I like are vulnerable on the page, I feel a little empowered in my own way.

Sam Aureli's avatar

If our unfurling lasts only a brief moment, let it be wild beauty, a bright light. Even if only for a day, let us dazzle the skies. Keep writing, my friend. Keep dazzling those skies.

Wholeheartedly Marge MacKeith's avatar

I had just closed the Substack window on my computer having decided not to share a poem and then I received this email. I believe it is telling me to go back and hit Send to everyone now.

Karen Hoffman's avatar

"Feel the fear and do it anyway!"

I'm reading this on Mother's day morning, thinking about all the care givers out there - including you! You are surely holding your mother in your heart, as are many others.

All I can say is, thank heaven for Mrs. Brown!!!

Gayla Dunn's avatar

I’d love to hear the poem recited by the 8 year old you.

Your words continue to be beautiful, encouraging and so inspiring to so many. ❤️🙏❤️

Lisa Jensen's avatar

This is just lovely! I happened to stumble across your long-ago podcast interview with Eric Zimmer yesterday, and so I got to hear a little bit about your grade-school courage as a writer . . . love this poem, loved the interview. Thank you for the beauty you put into the world.

Michael Ross's avatar

"It was all I had to give..." wow.

Mahdi Meshkatee's avatar

Yours is a struggle we all share, and I thank you for giving voice to that struggle. It’s more than enough.

Jenna Wysong Filbrun's avatar

Beautiful and so touching. Thank you for this, James. I needed this message today. Your work is such a gift.

Poetry Tracks In the Snow's avatar

I love these parallel stories James 💛

The Sawyer's Daughter's avatar

Soothing reassuring words of grace and comfort. I love and admire your gentle ways, my friend!

Lynn Harrison's avatar

Beautiful poem and essay. Thank you for sharing your story, which is very helpful to me personally.

Sarah Thompson's avatar

"What I do is enough", now there's a mantra to try and live by. Thank you for sharing your words and vulnerability with us today, James. I wasn't quite as brave as you at 8, but I remember a similar moment of joyous recognition when my English teacher told me, at 14, that I should become a writer (based on the short story I'd just written for class), not knowing that it was my fondest wish and secret dream.